I'll get things started with a few suggestions.
I've voted for @Kid Jericho and @MonsooN the past couple of occasions so it'd be remiss of me not to mention them. Two fresher shouts from me would be in the form of @Ness and @Matt who have both been quality posters here for over a decade. Matt has worked tirelessly, modding and posting in the wrestling sections for so long. I sometimes think he's the most underrated poster we've had here. Ness has long been a staple of Fan Fic and The Nerdery, he's always been a good contributor 'up north', and he's been the MVP of the Coliseum for the past couple of years. He deserves recognition for his dedication with his video promos, alone.