The idea was good in theory, but was never going to work out. The idea of throwing out the participation trophies was enticing. I like the list, but I don't love it by any means. Absolute joke that "Captain Intangibles" Jonathan Toews and Patrick Kane made the list. I've even seen compelling arguments against Duncan Keith making the list. Malkin, Thornton, and Iginla not making the list....no. You can even think of Chara for the list.